Page 2 of 2

Posted: Dec 26th, '11, 21:23
by L'Arc
«minah» wrote:^
I'm not sure if Shinzanmono is underrated... it's based on Higashino's novel (pretty much all dramas adapted from him are usually good and looked on positively) and it already had a SP & a movie. Maybe on intl forums/sites it's underrated/not talked about too much (but I think even the the Shinzanmono thread here had many people commenting ^^)
You're right maybe it's because I rarely see it mentioned around here that I thought it was underrated.

It's a must see anyway. I still listen to the soundtrack to this day :P

Posted: May 12th, '13, 09:14
by lontong.stroong
My personal most underrated drama ever:

Medaka
better than almost all school drama, the first 5 episodes are great

Suzuki Sensei
Very different type of school drama, shame it only got very low rating due to airing time, but personally this is best school-themed drama you can get.

Shinya Shokudo (both seasons)
Nice soothing slice of life drama

Suika
Yup this is it, the most underrated dorama ever! Heartwarming and offbeat at the same time and excellent cast who were all very well characterized.

Posted: May 15th, '13, 10:31
by funretrolook
ecco27 wrote:Ahh all this talk about Utahime. I loved Utahime at the time, it was one of the first dramas I finished and I was so sad about the ratings because I think it was better than that. I liked Suzu and I'm not crazy about Aibu now but back then I hadn't seen her in anything else. Yeah I was a bit disappointed with the ending and I found many of the characters annoying at some point but overall I really liked it.
When I saw this topic, Utahime was the first title that came to my mind, but I didn't expect to find a whole string of replies discussing Utahime on this thread! Well I'm glad to know I'm not the only one who feels it's one of the most underrated J-dramas ever aired. I just finished rewatching it yesterday, and I still loved it as much as I did the first time. I still think it's one of the best endings I've seen.

Posted: May 15th, '13, 11:27
by DragonSpikeXIII
Homework and Okane ga nai! are two great 90's doramas that don't seem to get much appreciation.

Posted: May 15th, '13, 13:36
by lontong.stroong
funretrolook wrote:
ecco27 wrote:Ahh all this talk about Utahime. I loved Utahime at the time, it was one of the first dramas I finished and I was so sad about the ratings because I think it was better than that. I liked Suzu and I'm not crazy about Aibu now but back then I hadn't seen her in anything else. Yeah I was a bit disappointed with the ending and I found many of the characters annoying at some point but overall I really liked it.
When I saw this topic, Utahime was the first title that came to my mind, but I didn't expect to find a whole string of replies discussing Utahime on this thread! Well I'm glad to know I'm not the only one who feels it's one of the most underrated J-dramas ever aired. I just finished rewatching it yesterday, and I still loved it as much as I did the first time. I still think it's one of the best endings I've seen.
Utahime is underrated indeed despite its shortcomings

Has pacing issue especially in the middle, however its 4 first episodes were so funny and entertaining, as well as strong and pretty unusual ending which I really fond of.
The ending is predictable though, if you pay enough attention to it. I realized Suzu would end up with Croissant when he told his name as "Matsu no Croissant". The late owner (present time) of the cinema was by the name of Matsunaka
DragonSpikeXIII wrote:Homework and Okane ga nai! are two great 90's doramas that don't seem to get much appreciation.
Newer jdrama watchers should go and watch Okane ga Nai! I heard this series was popular by the time of its airing, but I doubt younger generations know this gem

Posted: Aug 11th, '13, 14:30
by YukawaManabu
How about Sakai Masato's JOKER? I don't know why it isn't much of a commercial success but it was pretty good. He's a wonderful actor.

Re: Top 5 most underrated jdramas

Posted: Aug 29th, '15, 12:30
by pearlyriver
Considering that the last post in this thread was 2 years ago, I'd love to hear more recommendations for underrated jdramas recently. A lot of dramas shown in the midnight slot turn out to be quite good and deserve more attention.

Re: Top 5 most underrated jdramas

Posted: Aug 29th, '15, 15:47
by lontong.stroong
pearlyriver wrote:Considering that the last post in this thread was 2 years ago, I'd love to hear more recommendations for underrated jdramas recently. A lot of dramas shown in the midnight slot turn out to be quite good and deserve more attention.
Lunch no Akko-chan
Gin Nikan
Yuube no Curry, Ashita no Pan

Re: Top 5 most underrated jdramas

Posted: Aug 30th, '15, 05:02
by pearlyriver
lontong.stroong wrote:
pearlyriver wrote:Considering that the last post in this thread was 2 years ago, I'd love to hear more recommendations for underrated jdramas recently. A lot of dramas shown in the midnight slot turn out to be quite good and deserve more attention.
Lunch no Akko-chan
Gin Nikan
Yuube no Curry, Ashita no Pan
Thank you. I'm on the fence about the first and third suggestions but you've given me a reason to watch them. I'll give the second a try as well. I said that dramas witht unfavorable timeslots tend to be overlooked, but I'm open to suggestions for dramas in other timeslots that are underrated as well.

I've noticed that NHK dramas, with the exception of Taiga and Asadora, tend to be more over looked. Are they too sanitized for people's tastes?

Re: Top 5 most underrated jdramas

Posted: Aug 30th, '15, 10:36
by uedajirou
Double Kicthen
Jyoou no Kyoushitsu
Nasake no Onna
Oniyome Nikki

Re: Top 5 most underrated jdramas

Posted: Aug 30th, '15, 16:45
by lontong.stroong
pearlyriver wrote:
lontong.stroong wrote:
pearlyriver wrote:Considering that the last post in this thread was 2 years ago, I'd love to hear more recommendations for underrated jdramas recently. A lot of dramas shown in the midnight slot turn out to be quite good and deserve more attention.
Lunch no Akko-chan
Gin Nikan
Yuube no Curry, Ashita no Pan
Thank you. I'm on the fence about the first and third suggestions but you've given me a reason to watch them. I'll give the second a try as well. I said that dramas witht unfavorable timeslots tend to be overlooked, but I'm open to suggestions for dramas in other timeslots that are underrated as well.

I've noticed that NHK dramas, with the exception of Taiga and Asadora, tend to be more over looked. Are they too sanitized for people's tastes?
Possibly. The audience loves more flashy and try-to-look-cool dramas. Aside of that, just like WOWOW's counterparts, they tend to cast real actors, who are unfortunately likely to be less popular than that of mainstream channels.

Oh and I just forgot to add Genkai Shuraku Kabukigaisha to the current underrated list.

Re: Top 5 most underrated jdramas

Posted: Sep 1st, '15, 13:38
by KoChun
> With Love
theme: internet with bank teller and composer http://wiki.d-addicts.com/With_Love

> Hagane no Onna (season 1)
theme: school http://asianwiki.com/The_Woman_of_Steel ... no_Onna%29

> Deiri Kinshi no Onna
theme: investigative reporter http://wiki.d-addicts.com/Deiri_Kinshi_no_Onna

> Jyouou (season 1)
theme: night club http://asianwiki.com/Jyouou

> Miyamoto Musashi SP
theme: warring state era savage turn ronin turn master swordsmanhttp://asianwiki.com/Miyamoto_Musashi_SP

Re: Top 5 most underrated jdramas

Posted: Sep 1st, '15, 17:34
by uedajirou
Ah.. I forget:
1. Beginner (The one about lawyer, with Mimura etc)
2. Egao no Hosoku
3. Suika
4. At home dad

Re: Top 5 most underrated jdramas

Posted: May 20th, '16, 10:13
by JackBauer2424
The main site often lists ratings. Is there a database that can generate a list of Japanese dramas by ratings? Or a particular actor's dramas sorted by best ratings? Mysteries/suspense by best ratings? Police dramas by ratings? Romance by ratings?

I noticed some of the stinkers I watched were like less than 16%, but the better ones were like 20% or 30%. There were some I liked that had around 10% ratings. I'm curious what else got 20% to 30% ratings. I was surprised Musashi with Ryoko Yonekura didn't get great ratings.

I watched two episodes of With Love and not likely to watch the entire series.

Re: Top 5 most underrated jdramas

Posted: Aug 12th, '18, 03:32
by ChaleChangZambarau
With Love
Lady Joker
Atami no Sousahan
Ashita Kita no Yoshio
Zettai Kareshi

Re: Top 5 most underrated jdramas

Posted: Aug 12th, '18, 08:24
by SusieQ
Well, since this topic is revived, what are some underrated/underwatched dramas from 2015 until now?

Re: Top 5 most underrated jdramas

Posted: Aug 15th, '19, 14:27
by Yanez
SusieQ wrote:
Aug 12th, '18, 08:24
Well, since this topic is revived, what are some underrated/underwatched dramas from 2015 until now?
Hmmm...from 2015 on?
Here's 5 of them I think (I may be mistaken though) were not so popular - and I loved all of them:
(in reverse chronological order)

Koisuru Hong Kong
Otoko Meshi
Juhan Shuttai!
Teddy Go!
Koi no Sanriku Ressha Kon de Iko!

...and I'd also like to name "Prison School", which, albeit being probably popular (I'm not sure, but I have the feeling it was) really surprised me for being a lot wittier than I had expected it to be...

5 more titles which didn't make my "top5underrated" for the aforementioned period but went very close to doing so were:

Tsubaki Bunguten
Hannari Girori no Yoriko-san
Garasu no Ashi
Wakako Zake
Seigi no Se

:wink:

Re: Top 5 most underrated jdramas

Posted: Aug 29th, '19, 01:11
by hhnd
Came back to add Kazoku no katachi (2016). I wasn't familiar with the script writer and watched it for Juri, but in the end I loved everything about the drama. It really resonates with my generation, the Millenials, who are ruining everything in the world - retail, earth population, etc :D It's (mostly) realistic and touching, and nothing about it feels forced. It is now one of my all time favorites.