D-Addicts's Ranking for 2005 JDramas (finished, results in)

Dorobou · Post by **Dorobou** » Dec 21st, '05, 16:51

Thanks for the notice, my bad.

groink · Post by **groink** » Dec 21st, '05, 20:50

Wild Cherry wrote:
Sofyx wrote: densha no otoko, 5 (completely overrated, wow i found this incredibly boring, who wants to watch people talk across the internet, and the way the protagonist talks is also agitating)
Glad I'm not the only one who thought that.

I haven't even WATCHED the series. Themes like a dork checking out a beautiful woman just doesn't hit me as having enough substance for me to burn a few hours over. Here's an idea for a SP... What they should do next is have this otoku appear on Dr. Phil and have the good doctor straighten him out.

--- groink

GoldenMountain · Post by **GoldenMountain** » Dec 21st, '05, 21:43

25 Jyoou no Kyoushitsu
20 1 Litre no Namida
15 M no Higeki
10 Yasashii Jikan
10 Ruri no Shima
10 Tiger and Dragon
10 Nobuta wo Produce

mission · Post by **mission** » Dec 21st, '05, 23:10

Tiger & Dragon - 25
Anego - 20
Slow Dance - 15
Engine - 13
Ganbatte Ikimasshoi - 12
Nobuta wo Produce - 10
Densha Otoko - 5

ahhhhh the pressure...i can´t think about it anymore. just take my list away from me and let it be done. hours and hours...

shun · Post by **shun** » Dec 21st, '05, 23:16

Densha Otoko 20
Nobuta Wo Produce 20
Gokusen 2 20
Engine 20
1 Litre No Namida 10
Kiken Na Aneki 5
Brother Beat 3
Chakushin Ari 2

mallepa · Post by **mallepa** » Dec 22nd, '05, 03:31

Tiger & Dragon 20
anego 20
Dragonzakura 20
Nobuta wo Produce 20
Hana Yori Dango 20

My top dramas of the year ^-^

babo_ck · Post by **babo_ck** » Dec 22nd, '05, 05:06

1 Litre of Tears : 20
Nobuta wo Produce :35
Hana Yori Dango: :30
Densha Otoko :15

i didnt watch a lot of jdoramas this year

spacecommand · Post by **spacecommand** » Dec 22nd, '05, 06:53

Densha Otoko 25points
H2 25points
Kiken na Aneki 25points
Kyumei Byoto 24 Ji 3 (Aka. 24 Hours Emergency Ward 3) 25points

---
I know this doesnt count, but very high RETRO VOTES for dramas that were aired in Japan prior to 2005, but didn't make its way onto d-addicts until 2005.

Sekai No Chushin (2004) !!!
Fire Boys (2004)
Stewardess Monogatari (1983)

betty617hk · Post by **betty617hk** » Dec 22nd, '05, 07:28

Koi ni Ochitara Boku no Seikou no Himitsu 20
M no Higeki 15
Dragon Zakura 10
Nobuta wo Produce 20
Hana yori dango 15
H2 10
Slow dance 10

yt_toshi · Post by **yt_toshi** » Dec 22nd, '05, 07:37

babo_ck wrote:1 Litre of Tears : 20
Nobuta wo Produce :35
Hana Yori Dango: :30
Densha Otoko :15

i didnt watch a lot of jdoramas this year

Remember, the maximum amount of points a drama gets is 25, and not 30 or 35.

theedqueen · Post by **theedqueen** » Dec 22nd, '05, 07:39

Densha Otoko - 25
Hana Yori Dango - 25
Nobuta wo Produce - 20
Gokusen 2 - 18
Engine - 5

yt_toshi · Post by **yt_toshi** » Dec 22nd, '05, 07:39

spacecommand wrote:Densha Otoko 20points
H2 40points
Kiken na Aneki 20points
Kyumei Byoto 24 Ji 3 (Aka. 24 Hours Emergency Ward 3) 20points

Remember, the maximum amount of points a drama gets is 25, and not 40.

Nelly · Post by **Nelly** » Dec 22nd, '05, 07:52

Dragon Zakura 15
Nobuta wo Produce 15
Oniyome Nikki 20
1 Litre Tears 20
Joou no kyoushitsu 20
Hana yori dango 10

toyotaku · Post by **toyotaku** » Dec 22nd, '05, 08:50

Dorobou wrote: Densha Otoko - 20 (because of Sakurai, you know, the evo guy)

My new best friend!

ina · Post by **ina** » Dec 22nd, '05, 22:15

Hana Yori Dango - 15
Nobuta wo produce - 25
Densha Otoko - 10
Anego - 25
Gokusen 2 - 15
Dragon Zakura - 10

Wpg Drama · Post by **Wpg Drama** » Dec 22nd, '05, 22:47

Slow Dance - 25
Hana Yori Dango - 25
Brother Beat - 15
Densha Otoko - 10
Engine - 10
H2 - 10
Nobuta wo Produce - 5

Karo · Post by **Karo** » Dec 22nd, '05, 22:52

Nobuta o produce - 25
1 litre of tears - 20
hana yori dango - 20
Anego - 15
densha otoko - 10
Gokusen 2 - 10

laure_choc · Post by **laure_choc** » Dec 22nd, '05, 22:56

Ai No Uta:10
H2:14
Hana Yori Dango:11
Hiroshima Showa 20 nen 8 Gatsu Muike:3
Hotaru no haka:6
Ichi Rittoru no Namida:17
Rokusen Nin Inochi no Visa:6
Start Line:8 (this one managed to make me cry raw, i don't know what it wouldl be with subs

)
Yasashii Jikan:25

it can be quite hard when there are too many dramas, wow i did it

Seghal · Post by **Seghal** » Dec 22nd, '05, 23:11

laure_choc wrote:Start Line:8 (this one managed to make me cry raw, i don't know what it wouldl be with subs )

Me too.

laure_choc wrote:Yasashii Jikan:25

nanachan · Post by **nanachan** » Dec 23rd, '05, 04:49

1litre of tears - 25
hana yori dango - 15
Engine - 15
nobuta wo produce - 10
Gokusen2 - 5
Anego - 5
densha otoko -5

cupids · Post by **cupids** » Dec 23rd, '05, 08:03

here's mine!:

i only watched nobuta! so here goes

Nobuta wo produce: 25 pts!

Ruroshin · Post by **Ruroshin** » Dec 23rd, '05, 10:06

Top 10 so far

Nobuta wo Produce
Hana Yori Dango
Densha Otoko
Ichi Rittoru no Namida
H2
Engine
Anego
Dragon Zakura
Gokusen 2
Slow Dance

* top 4 now have 4 digit points
* Dragon Zakura drops 2 places
* Anego jumps 3 places
* Koi ni Ochitara just misses out on top 10

only a week left until end of 2005

andiephung · Post by **andiephung** » Dec 23rd, '05, 10:23

hana yori dango 25

debstuh · Post by **debstuh** » Dec 23rd, '05, 10:40

laure_choc · Post by **laure_choc** » Dec 23rd, '05, 10:46

Seghal wrote:
laure_choc wrote:Yasashii Jikan:25

Nice to see someone else liked this drama

Maybe many will discover it on 2006

jenn · Post by **jenn** » Dec 23rd, '05, 11:04

Nobuta wo Produce - 25
Hana Yori Dango - 15
1 Rittoru no Namida - 20

surezal · Post by **surezal** » Dec 23rd, '05, 14:10

Densha Otoko - 25
Hana Yori Dango - 25 (well, want to give more points but it isnt possible

)
Gokusen - 25

Post by **xiaryx** » Dec 23rd, '05, 19:16

Densha Otoko 25
Jyoou no Kyoushitsu 20
Slow Dance 30
Nobuta wo Produce 25

DareDesuKa · Post by **DareDesuKa** » Dec 24th, '05, 04:46

Koi ni Ochitara Boku no Seikou no Himitsu 25
Densha Otoko 20
Ame to Yume no Ato ni 20
Haruka 17 20
Yoshitsune 15

I LOVE koi ni ochitara, one of my all time favorite... wow, kinda hard to believe that aired this year...

Yoshitsune... wish i was able to see all of it, I'll catch up someday, I hope.

Haruka 17 is really under sppriciated. Yeah, it's not deeply intelectual or emotional, but it's a well done comedy imho.

soscarygs · Post by **soscarygs** » Dec 24th, '05, 07:06

Ones that I watched

Ichi ... namida : 25
Nobuta wo Produce: 25
H2: 10
Densha Otoko: 10
Hana Yori Dango: 10

yt_toshi · Post by **yt_toshi** » Dec 24th, '05, 07:19

xiaryx wrote:Slow Dance 30

Ruroshin said that you can have a maximum of 25 points per drama, not 30

*kawaii* · Post by ***kawaii*** » Dec 24th, '05, 10:49

can i vote for 2 dramas only?

for me:-

Hana Yori Dango 25

Nobuta wo Produce 25

^_^

Benoist-lover · Post by **Benoist-lover** » Dec 24th, '05, 11:10

Densha Otoko 25
Hana Yori Dango 25
Gokusen 2 25

Then I haven't watched more dramas made 2005.

Wut · Post by **Wut** » Dec 24th, '05, 15:51

for me,

Densha Otoko : 25
Anego : 25
H2 : 20
Engine : 10
Kiken na Aneki : 10
Nobuta wo Produce : 10

herbert · Post by **herbert** » Dec 24th, '05, 16:47

Yasashii Jikan 25
Nobuta wo Produce 15
Tokyo Friends 15
Slow Dance 15
Hana Yori Dango 10
Kiken na Aneki 10
Anego 10

neme_chan · Post by **neme_chan** » Dec 24th, '05, 22:57

anego 15
densha otoko 20
hana yori dango 20
ichi ritoru no namida 15
nobuta wo produce 20
yasashii jikan 10

waffer · Post by **waffer** » Dec 24th, '05, 23:14

Densha Otoko - 22
Hana Yori Dango - 21
Nobuta wo Produce - 21
Anego - 16
Gokusen 2 - 15
Tiger and Dragon - 5

donna8157 · Post by **donna8157** » Dec 24th, '05, 23:27

Densha Otoko - 15
Engine - 15
Anego - 10
Tiger and Dragon - 20
Ganbatte Ikimasshoi! - 10
Nobuta wo Produce - 15
Gokusen 2 - 5
Hana Yori Dango - 10

sakura_r0se · Post by **sakura_r0se** » Dec 24th, '05, 23:31

Densha Otoko - 25
Hana Yori Dango - 25
Brother Beat - 23
Nobuta wo Produce - 23

gomi · Post by **gomi** » Dec 24th, '05, 23:51

My Long List:

Nobuta wo Produce > 25
Tiger & Dragon > 20
Engine > 20
Hana Yori Dango > 10
Dragon Zakura > 8
Densha > 5
Gokusen2 > 4
Ichi Rittoru no Namida > 4
Koini Ochitara > 1
Kyomei Byoto 24 Ji 3 > 1
Slow Dance > 1
Kekenna Aneki > 1

minerva · Post by **minerva** » Dec 25th, '05, 18:47

20 Koi ni Ochitara
20 Hana Yori Dango
19 1 Rittoru no Namida
19 Jyouu no Kyoshitsu
12 Ruri no SHima
10 Densha no Otoko

Miyoubi · Post by **Miyoubi** » Dec 25th, '05, 22:31

Nobuta wo produce 25
Hana yori dango 20
Anego 20
Densha Otoko 15
Gokusen2 15
Yoshitsune 10

ermac · Post by **ermac** » Dec 25th, '05, 23:31

~Engine - 25
~Densha Otoko - 20
~Hana Yori Dango - 20
~H2 - 15
~Kindaichi Shonen no Jikenbo - 10
~Ganbatte Ikimasshoi - 10

amulet · Post by **amulet** » Dec 25th, '05, 23:49

i haven't watch a lot of J-drama but I go for
Hana yori dango -25

groink · Post by **groink** » Dec 25th, '05, 23:56

amulet wrote:i haven't watch a lot of J-drama but I go for
Hana yori dango -25

Holy cow! A Candy Candy avatar! Cool!

AsianRice · Post by **AsianRice** » Dec 26th, '05, 01:47

Ichi Rittoru no Namida 25
Nobuta wo Produce 20
Densha Otoko 20
Brother Beat 15
Hana Yori Dang 10
Gokusen S2 10

panthera · Post by **panthera** » Dec 26th, '05, 01:55

nobuta wo produce 25
hana yori dango 20
brother beat 15
dragon zakura 5
densha otoko 17
anego 5
gokusen 2 13

Prince of Moles · Post by **Prince of Moles** » Dec 26th, '05, 06:36

Tiger and Dragon 25

Densha Otoko 10

Oniyome Nikki 10

Kikujiro to Saki 10

Dragonzakura 7

ahaw · Post by **ahaw** » Dec 26th, '05, 06:49

Densha Otoko - 25

Gokusen 2 - 25

Ganbatte Ikimasshoi! - 25

cuz that the latest drama i've watched....(feel sorry for others drama

)

:bunny: · Post by **:bunny:** » Dec 26th, '05, 07:02

hmmmm this is really tough

Hana Yori Dango - 25
Nobuta Wo Produce - 20
Densha Otoko - 20
Engine - 15
Koi Ni Ochitara - 10
Jyoou no Kyoushitsu - 10

masaka___ · Post by **masaka___** » Dec 26th, '05, 16:27

Densha Otoko - 25

Gokusen 2 - 25

Kiken na Aneki - 14

I haven't watched anything else.

nikochanr3 · Post by **nikochanr3** » Dec 26th, '05, 18:03

Densha Otoko 25

Ai no Uta 25

1 Littoru no Namida 25 :cry
Konya Hitori no Beddo De 10

:
Kikenna Aneki 10

Hana Yori no Dango 5

pipi · Post by **pipi** » Dec 26th, '05, 20:35

Nobuta wo Produce 25
Ichi Rittoru no Namida 25
Dragon Zakura 20
Gambatte Ikimasshoi 15
Haruka 17 15

Sponton · Post by **Sponton** » Dec 26th, '05, 20:47

Hana Yori Dango: 25
Dragon Zakura: 25
Nobuta wo Produce: 15
H2: 5
Gokusen 2: 5

1Yen · Post by **1Yen** » Dec 26th, '05, 21:30

Nobuta wo Produce : 15
Densha Otoko : 20
Hana Yori Dango : 12
Dragonzakura : 12
Gokusen II : 7
Engine : 10
Jyoou no Kyoushitsu : 7
H2 : 17

Shindou-Kun · Post by **Shindou-Kun** » Dec 26th, '05, 21:49

Nobuta wo Produce 25
Engine 25
Hana Yori Dango 20
Jyoou no Kyoushitsu 15
Dragon Sakura 10
Densha Otoko 5

My votes for Jdrama 2005

Midori-Yagami · Post by **Midori-Yagami** » Dec 26th, '05, 21:51

Engine: 25
Nobuta wo produce: 20
1 litre of tears: 18
Ima ai ni yukimasu: 15
Gokusen2: 10

sunmoon · Post by **sunmoon** » Dec 26th, '05, 22:32

Engine 25
Nobuta wo Produce 20
1 Litre of Tears 20
Dragon Zakura 15
Hana Yori dango: 10

Vanilla_Spider__x · Post by **Vanilla_Spider__x** » Dec 28th, '05, 10:26

Hana Yori Dango- 25
Densha Otoko- 25
Nobuta wo Produce- 25
Gokusen 2- 15
Gambatte Ikimasshoi- 10

beccaa · Post by **beccaa** » Dec 28th, '05, 10:40

hana yori dango- 25
nobuta wo produce- 23
dragon zakura- 20

orenji · Post by **orenji** » Dec 28th, '05, 10:53

M no Higeki - 10
Koi ni Ochitara - 10
Engine - 10
Slow Dance - 10
Kyumei Byoto 3 - 10
Magarikado no Kanojo - 10
Ima, Ai ni Yukimasu - 5

Asuka e, soshite mada minu ko e - 25
Hotaru no Haka - 10

Ruroshin · Post by **Ruroshin** » Dec 28th, '05, 11:29

Top 10 so far:

Nobuta wo Produce
Hana Yori Dango
Densha Otoko
Ichi Rittoru no Namida
Engine
Gokusen 2
H2
Dragon Zakura
Anego
Slow Dance

* Some of the top 10 shuffled around a bit
* Koi ni Ochitara just missed out on top 10
* 54 dramas have been voted on so far
* 165 votes have been counted.

only a few days left in the year I will close the voting on the new year and announce the ranking and their points. I will also probably make the top 3 part of the permanent seeding project.

isuzu · Post by **isuzu** » Dec 28th, '05, 11:36

hana yori dango 25
one litre of tears 23
Gambatte Ikkamashoi 20
brother beat 15
nobuta wo produce 10
Densha Otoko 7

Shizuru · Post by **Shizuru** » Dec 28th, '05, 11:50

Nobuta Wo Produce > 25
H2 > 25
Hana Yori Dango > 20
Dragon Zakura > 15
Densha Otoko > 10
Gokusen 2 > 5

dan12 · Post by **dan12** » Dec 28th, '05, 17:11

1 litre o tears 25
nobuta 15\
hana yori dango 15

timmonsgray · Post by **timmonsgray** » Dec 28th, '05, 18:17

Kiken na Aneki - 5
Anego - 8
Aikurushii - 2
Nobuta wo produce - 16
Hana yori dango - 7
Shiawase ni naritai - 3
Densha Otoko - 18
Joou no Kyoushitsu - 20
Magari kado no kanojo - 2
Tiger and Dragon - 8
Engine - 1
Gokusen 2 - 8
Kyumei Byoto 24ji 3 - 1
Minna mukashi wa kodomo datta - 1

My favorites would be JnK, Nobuta, and Densha. Tiger and Dragon probably had some of the most innovative storytelling though. Gokusen 2 was a big copy of the first season, but the acting is so funny, that it's still fun to watch.

Ikematsusosuke · Post by **Ikematsusosuke** » Dec 29th, '05, 02:58

ichi rittoru no namida = 25pts
engine = 25pts
koi no ochitara = 25pts
densha otoko = 10pts
nobuta no produce = 10pts
hana yori dango = 5pts

YamaPi_4Ever · Post by **YamaPi_4Ever** » Dec 29th, '05, 03:20

Nobuta Wo Produce >>>>> 25

Dragon Zakura >>>>>>>> 20
1 Litre Of Tears >>>>>>>20
Brother Beat >>>>>>>>15
Gokusen 2 >>>>>>>>10
Gokusen >>>>>>>>10
That all I watch so far ..

starryeyed · Post by **starryeyed** » Dec 30th, '05, 06:51

Here's my choice:

Nobuta wa produce>>>-25
Ai no Uta ->>>25
I litre of tears ->>15
Densha Otoko ->>15
Dragon Zakura ->>15
Hana Yori Dango - >>5

Prince of Moles · Post by **Prince of Moles** » Dec 30th, '05, 08:11

Here is the Oricon chart for the best JDrama series 2005.

http://news.oricon.co.jp/omr/7563.html

I must say that I am surprised in the list but anyway 1-10:

1 Emergency Room 24H

2 Tiger and Dragon

3 Umizaru

4 Gokusen

5 1 lt of tears

6 Densha otoko

7 Divorce Lawyer

8 Koi in ochitara (Falling in Love)

9 Dragonzakura

10 Ooku: Hana no ran (Shogun's Harem)

nicpkh · Post by **nicpkh** » Dec 30th, '05, 08:34

Here is my rank for 2005
1. Densha Otoko ---- 25
2. Nobuta Wo Produce ---- 25
3. Gambatte Ikimasshoi ---- 25
4. 1 Litre Of Tears ---- 25
Hehehe that will be enough 100 points hehe...

HAPPY NEW YEAR......[/list][/list]

koolaid · Post by **koolaid** » Dec 30th, '05, 09:27

I am glad that this thread was here. It made me take a look at Nobuta wo Produce, and I must say that I am enjoying the series. I mean it must be ranked number one for some reason?

shirahime · Post by **shirahime** » Dec 30th, '05, 12:25

Prince of Moles wrote:Here is the Oricon chart for the best JDrama series 2005.

http://news.oricon.co.jp/omr/7563.html

I must say that I am surprised in the list but anyway 1-10:

1 Emergency Room 24H

2 Tiger and Dragon

3 Umizaru

4 Gokusen

5 1 lt of tears

6 Densha otoko

7 Divorce Lawyer

8 Koi in ochitara (Falling in Love)

9 Dragonzakura

10 Ooku: Hana no ran (Shogun's Harem)

11. Yasashii jikan

12. Hana yori dango

13. Anego

14. Nobuta wo produce

15. Ima ai ni...

16. Ruri no shima

17. Ai no uta

18. Aikurushi

19. Ganbatte ikimasho

20. Nyokei Kazoku

hm very interesting, I guess because there's a lot of fangirls here

tissa · Post by **tissa** » Dec 30th, '05, 18:20

ichi rittoru no namida: 25
Nobuta wo produce: 20
Hana yori dango: 15
Ganbatte ikimasshoi: 10
Dragon Zakura: 10
Attack No.1: 10
Gokusen 2: 10

shime · Post by **shime** » Dec 30th, '05, 18:27

ichi rittoru no namida: 25
nobuta wo produce: 20
anego: 10
densha otoko: 5

Asian DramaWiki Forum

D-Addicts's Ranking for 2005 JDramas (finished, results in)

Who is online